Start with the entry price, then check what it buys
The lowest advertised price is the fastest way to separate these providers, but it only means something once you know what sits above it. ATG Tickets lists attraction tickets and gift cards and prices them from €10, with a market limited to DE. mydays and Jochen Schweizer both start lower, at €5.90 and €5.90, and both sell across DE, AT and CH, which matches the DE, AT and CH listed for Jochen Schweizer. DealToday sits at €1 and covers a single market, MT.
Those floor prices are deliberately low anchors, so treat them as entry points rather than typical spends. Across the tickets in our data, entry prices run €0 to €161.54, which shows how wide the spread can be between a cheap single entry and a larger package. Sort each catalogue by price and look at where your intended attraction actually sits, not just the cheapest item on the page.
Product type matters for the same reason. ATG Tickets is listed with attractions and gift cards only, while mydays and Jochen Schweizer cover attractions alongside experience days, spa, driving, adventure, food and drink and gift cards, and DealToday adds spa and food and drink to its attractions and gift cards. If you want an attraction plus a meal or a spa day on one voucher, the two names on this list will hold more options.
Voucher validity is the quietest cost
A cheap ticket is poor value if it expires before you can use it. Voucher lengths across the tickets in our data run 12 to 39 months, so the same price can be worth very different amounts depending on how quickly you plan to go.
Within that range, mydays and Jochen Schweizer both list vouchers valid for 36 months, and both also allow exchanges. DealToday lists a shorter window of 12 months and does allow exchanges as well. ATG Tickets is exchangeable too, though its validity period is not set out in the terms we list.
The practical comparison is simple: a longer validity period makes a ticket a safer present, because a recipient can pick their own date. A shorter one suits a buyer who already knows when they want to go. If you are buying for someone else, weight exchangeability and validity above the entry price.
Returns, delivery and the money left on the table
Every provider here lists a return window of 14 days, matching 14 days at Jochen Schweizer and 14 days at DealToday. That consistency means you do not need to pick a winner on returns alone; you can rule a provider out only if it has no stated window.
Delivery is where the providers separate. Jochen Schweizer offers next day delivery and charges a shipping fee of €4.90, so the headline price of €5.90 is not the landed cost of a physical voucher. mydays sells into the same set of markets but no shipping fee is listed, so add that to your comparison. ATG Tickets and DealToday list no delivery charge, though a digital gift card can change the picture entirely.
Support details are listed for three of the four providers. The email, phone and help centre at mydays match the email, phone and help centre at Jochen Schweizer and the email, phone and help centre at DealToday, each covering email, phone and a help centre. ATG Tickets does not set out a support channel alongside those, so check how you would reach its team before you commit to a ticket from it.
Company background as a stability check
A longer trading history is a reasonable tiebreaker when two providers look alike on price. mydays has been trading since 2003 and Jochen Schweizer since 1987, while ATG Tickets dates back to 1992.
Legal entities are listed for each: mydays GmbH, Jochen Schweizer GmbH, ATG Ticketing & Sales GmbH and Lovin Malta Deals Limited. Head offices sit in DE, DE and DE, with DealToday registered in MT. DealToday is the outlier here on both market reach and registration, which matters if you are redeeming anywhere other than a single market.
Catalogue size tells a similar story. Jochen Schweizer lists 9,000 experiences and mydays lists 10,448 experiences, though both figures cover every product type rather than attractions alone. A larger catalogue does not guarantee the specific venue you want, so check your date and venue before committing to a provider on volume alone.
Run your shortlist past independent reviews
Once price, validity and product type are on paper, read what other buyers say. Our Attraction tickets rankings put the providers side by side, and the individual reviews cover ATG Tickets, mydays, Jochen Schweizer and DealToday in more detail.
A simple scoring order works well. First, check whether your chosen attraction exists on the date you want. Second, add delivery to the entry price to get the real cost. Third, confirm the voucher validity period gives you room to use it. Brands such as Fever, Turbopass, Activity Superstore, FloridaTix and Virgin Experience Days are worth checking on the same three points if your shortlist reaches past this list.
That order keeps the decision factual. Price, validity and availability are the points that change what you pay, while catalogue size and founding year only break ties between offers that already look similar.