Updated 1 October 2026 · TreatCue Editorial Team

The Wine Society vs VINEBOX

The Wine Society logo

The Wine Society

No. 6 of 18 in wine clubs9.7

Best for: Drinkers in the United Kingdom, JE and GG wanting a club, a shop and a bottle guarantee in one place.

VINEBOX

No. 13 of 18 in wine clubs8.7

Best for: US drinkers who want a monthly case of wine and single bottles from the same brand.

See the category

Key differences

  • The Wine Society scores higher overall: 9.7 against 8.7.
  • Among support channels, only The Wine Society offers Phone and Community.
  • The Wine Society is available in 2 more countries.
  • Among products, only The Wine Society offers Spirits and Alcohol free.

Side by side

The Wine Society vs VINEBOX
The Wine Society logoThe Wine SocietyVINEBOX
Cost
Price fromNot listed$30above the median of 25 brands
Price per bottle£9.17 to £14.83$13.17
Free delivery threshold£0in the lowest quarter of 10 brandsNot listed
Offer
Bottles per box6 to 12 bottles6 bottles
Bottle guaranteeYesNo
Other facts
ProductsWine club, Wine shop, Spirits, Alcohol freeWine club, Wine shop
MarketsUnited Kingdom, Jersey, GuernseyUnited States
Delivery frequencyEvery two monthsMonthly
Company
Legal entityInternational Exhibition Co-Operative Wine Society LimitedVINEBOX Inc.
HeadquartersUnited KingdomUnited States
Founded1874Not listed
Support channelsPhone, Email, Help centre, CommunityEmail, Help centre

Our verdict on each

The Wine Society

The Wine Society runs a member club and a shop side by side, with club bottles at £9.17 to £14.83 a bottle guarantee behind every case. It suits drinkers in the United Kingdom, JE and GG who want club deliveries alongside a full shop.

Read the full The Wine Society review

VINEBOX

VINEBOX is a straightforward US wine club and bottle shop for drinkers who want 6 bottles delivered monthly, with single bottles in between. The club works out at $13.17 per bottle, and a bottle guarantee is not part of the deal.

Read the full VINEBOX review

How they place

Online wine shops
The Wine Society 72 of 106 by score · VINEBOX 86 of 106 by score

Pros and cons

The Wine Society

Pros

  • Club bottles run £9.17 to £14.83 a bottle, with 6 to 12 bottles in a case, easy to plan around.
  • Delivery is free: the free delivery threshold is £0, so a case costs its bottles and nothing more.
  • Support runs on phone, email and help centre, so a delivery question can go straight to a person by phone.

Cons

  • Cases arrive every two months, and that rhythm is the only cadence offered, so anyone drinking faster waits between deliveries.
  • The smallest case is the lower end of 6 to 12 bottles, a real commitment for a light drinker.

VINEBOX

Pros

  • The club bottle rate is $13.17 and the shop opens at $30, so both routes in are priced in the open.
  • A box is a full case of 6 bottles, which spreads a $5 shipping charge across plenty of bottles.
  • VINEBOX covers a wine club and a bottle shop, so a subscription is not the only way to buy.

Cons

  • There is no bottle guarantee, so a broken or corked bottle in a delivered case carries no stated cover.
  • Support runs on email and help centre only, so phone and live chat sit outside the service.
  • Next day delivery is not offered, and a $5 shipping charge lands on every order.

Who each suits

The Wine Society

Who it suits

  • Members who want a bottle guarantee and a person on phone, email and help centre when a case goes wrong.
  • Households that drink steadily and are happy with 6 to 12 bottles arriving on a every two months rhythm.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Beer-first drinkers: a beer club leads Beer52's beer club, wine club and spirits, not The Wine Society’s wine club, wine shop and spirits.
  • Shop-first browsers who want a shorter list, since Scout & Cellar keeps wine club and wine shop to club and shop only.
  • Buyers who want the club and the shop without extras, since Bright Cellars’ wine club and wine shop is a tighter pairing.

VINEBOX

Who it suits

  • US drinkers who want a case of 6 bottles on monthly deliveries, plus a shop for the bottles in between.
  • Gift buyers, because gift cards are exchangeable and personalization is offered.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Buyers outside US, since VINEBOX lists that market only and names no others.
  • Drinking families who want spirits or alcohol-free options: The Wine Society lists wine club, wine shop and spirits, a wider range than wine club and wine shop.
  • Beer drinkers, since Beer52 lists beer club, wine club and spirits and VINEBOX stays within wine.

Questions about each

The Wine Society

How much does a case of wine cost from The Wine Society?

The Society quotes club bottles at £9.17 to £14.83 a bottle. A case runs at 6 to 12 bottles, so the case total moves with the size you pick rather than following a single fixed price. Delivery is not the swing factor either, because the free delivery threshold is £0, which keeps a case close to the cost of its bottles.

Does The Wine Society charge for delivery?

There is no minimum order for free delivery: the free delivery threshold is £0, so the delivery charge is waived on every order rather than only above a spend level. You are not asked to build a basket to dodge a shipping line, which makes a small club case cost about what the bottles cost.

VINEBOX

What does a VINEBOX wine club box cost per month?

The subscription is priced at $13.17 per bottle, and each box holds 6 bottles, so a month costs that per-bottle rate multiplied by the case size. Nothing is quoted on request, which makes it easy to run the same calculation for other clubs before you commit to a plan.

Can I buy bottles without taking a subscription?

Yes. VINEBOX runs both plans under wine club and wine shop, so the club box is optional and the bottle shop stands on its own. Shop bottles start at $30, and a gift card can cover them too. Shop orders suit a drinker who wants a particular bottle for a dinner rather than a case on a schedule.

Sources

The Wine Society

  • thewinesociety.com: 11 facts, checked 30 September 2026

VINEBOX

  • vinebox.com: 10 facts, checked 30 September 2026