Chicago Steak Company review
Updated September 30, 2026 · TreatCue Editorial Team · Facts checked September 30, 2026
We earn a commission when you sign up through links on this site. Partner status can affect where a brand appears in our rankings.
Our verdict
Chicago Steak Company suits US households shopping for a single meat or seafood order, or a gourmet gift, with an entry price of $11.99 and a score of 9.1. Next day delivery and support on phone, email and chat make it a practical pick for quick gifting.
Key facts
- Best for
- A single US meat, seafood or gourmet gift order that needs to arrive quickly.
- Price from
- $11.99 (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
- Free delivery threshold
- $199 (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
- Next-day delivery
- Yes (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
- Markets
- US (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
- Legal entity
- Chicago Steak Company, Inc. (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
- Headquarters
- United States (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
- Founded
- 2008 (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
- Support channels
- Phone, Email, Chat, Help-centre (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
- Products
- Meat, Seafood, Gourmet, Chocolate, Snacks
- Official website
- mychicagosteak.com
Apps and profiles
- Elsewhere
- X
Pros and cons
Pros
- Items start at $11.99, which puts Chicago Steak Company at 31 of 65 in the site's price from ranking, so the low end is easy to reach.
- Next day delivery is offered, and free delivery applies from $199 on top of that.
- Product types run to meat, seafood and gourmet, so a gift chocolate order and a dinner meat order can travel together.
- Support runs on phone, email and chat, giving a phone line and chat alongside email and a help centre.
Cons
- Free delivery applies from $199, so a single steak or a chocolate purchase still carries a shipping charge.
- The catalogue stops short of a full grocery or cheese shop: meat, seafood and gourmet against cheese, meat and seafood at Zingerman's Artisan Cheese.
- Delivery covers US, so buyers outside the US cannot order.
Who it suits
- US households who want a single meat or seafood delivery in a hurry, since next day delivery is offered.
- Gift buyers combining chocolate and snacks with a meat order, given the meat, seafood and gourmet range.
- Shoppers who want a phone line on a larger order, with support on phone, email and chat.
Who should look elsewhere
- Cheese-led gift baskets, since Zingerman's Artisan Cheese covers cheese, meat and seafood.
- Anyone outside the US, because delivery is limited to US.
- Planners who want a fixed weekly menu rather than picking items, since HelloFresh centres on meat and seafood.
Pricing
The entry point is the item price rather than a plan, and products start at $11.99. That places the brand at 31 of 65 on the site's entry price comparison, so the cheapest way in is a single cut, a sauce or a confection rather than a full box. Meat sets and gourmet gift hampers sit well above that floor. Free delivery applies to orders of $199 and above, so shipping bites only on baskets under that line, and a regular buyer clears it without effort. The cost part of the score is 8.6, under the offer part at 9.7, which fits a catalogue where the low entry is easy to reach and the high end is not.
Who runs it
Chicago Steak Company, Inc. is the legal entity behind the store, and its headquarters sit in the US. Trading began in 2008, so the catalogue has been shaped by many seasons of holiday and gift orders rather than a recent launch. Support is the clearest strength: phone, email and chat are all available, and phone plus chat mean a delivery problem can be raised directly rather than left in an inbox. In a category where plenty of gift box names are new, a named US entity with a long trading record and broad support reach is the trust argument to make.
How Chicago Steak Company compares
- 9.1 vs 8.5
9.1 vs 8.5
9.1 vs 8.8
9.1 vs 9.4
9.1 vs 8.9
9.1 vs 8.5- 9.1 vs 9.6
9.1 vs 8.5
- 9.1 vs 8.4
9.1 vs 9.3- 9.1 vs 8.9
- 9.1 vs 9.2
- 9.1 vs 9.9
9.1 vs 9.5Meal kit focus, with meat and seafood centring on meat and seafood portions, which suits planners after a fixed menu instead of a single cut at $11.99.
9.1 vs 9.1
9.1 vs 9.0- 9.1 vs 8.7
- 9.1 vs 8.7
Gift Baskets Overseas
TeaVivre
One World Observatory
Watsons Wine
Concert
IGP
Kontramarka
Jebsen Wines and Spirits
Hungry Hub TH
Parmigiano Reggiano
Albert Wines MY
Siang Shuai Cake
Jinbo Selection
Taze Cicek
Righetto
El Dorado Water Park
JUNANDUS Cake Shop Malaysia
VinWonders
ProLon Europe
Flor2u
Winelab
Xpresent
FlowerAdvisor PH
Megatix TH
Ferns N Petals QA
Bloomeroo
GetYourGuide
Ticombo
Gametime
Where Chicago Steak Company is available
- Available
- United States
Countries from the brand (Source, checked September 30, 2026)
Frequently asked questions
What is the cheapest order at Chicago Steak Company?+
Prices start at $11.99. That is the entry point on individual items rather than a box, and it places Chicago Steak Company at 31 of 65 in the site's price from ranking. Free delivery applies from $199, so a small order lands under that bar and still carries shipping.
Does Chicago Steak Company charge for delivery?+
Delivery is free on orders of $199 and above. Below that level the shipping charge is added at checkout, so a single cut or a chocolate item costs more all in than its $11.99 sticker price. Larger meat sets and gourmet gift hampers are the orders that clear the free delivery bar comfortably.
How quickly can a Chicago Steak Company order arrive?+
Next day delivery is offered, so an order placed in time can arrive the following day in the US. That speed is the reason many buyers use the store for gifts and for a steak delivery inside a week. The catalogue covers meat, seafood and gourmet, so meat, seafood, gourmet items, chocolate and snacks can travel on the same next day slot.
What kinds of food does Chicago Steak Company sell?+
The range covers meat, seafood and gourmet. That is broader than Donald Russell's meat, seafood and gourmet and wider than HelloFresh's meat and seafood, because chocolate and snacks sit alongside the meat and seafood. It is narrower than Zingerman's Artisan Cheese, whose cheese, meat and seafood adds cheese and grocery.
Where does Chicago Steak Company deliver?+
Delivery covers US, and the company trades as Chicago Steak Company, Inc. from the US. Buyers outside the US are not served, which makes this a single market option next to brands with wider reach. Cost timing matters too: orders under $199 pick up a shipping charge on top of the item price.
How do I reach Chicago Steak Company support?+
Support runs on phone, email and chat. Phone suits a delivery that has gone wrong, chat suits a quick question while ordering, and the help centre covers routine cases. With next day delivery offered, having a phone route matters if a box lands short or arrives in poor condition.
Is Chicago Steak Company a new company?+
No. Trading began in 2008, and the store sells under Chicago Steak Company, Inc.. A record that long is useful context in a category where many gift box names are recent launches, and it suggests the support routes on phone, email and chat have settled into a routine rather than being temporary.
Which Chicago Steak Company products suit a value shopper?+
Price and range point the same way: entry at $11.99 on the smallest items, with the meat and seafood side of the catalogue behind the 31 placing of 65 on entry price. The meat, seafood and gourmet range means a single basket can carry a gift chocolate box and the steaks for dinner.
Sources
- mychicagosteak.com checked September 30, 2026
Backs: Founded
“TRUSTED SINCE 2008 Over 600,000 satisfied customers”
- mychicagosteak.com/collections/all checked September 30, 2026
Backs: Products
“Premium Angus Beef, USDA Prime - Wet Aged Beef, USDA Prime - Dry Aged Beef, American Wagyu Beef, Australian Wagyu Beef; 1lb Live Maine Lobsters, Alaskan King Crab Legs, Maryland Crab Cakes, Angus...”
- mychicagosteak.com/collections/all checked September 30, 2026
Backs: Price from
“1 Bottle Chicago Steak Seasoning - Sale price $11.99 Regular price $16.99”
- mychicagosteak.com/pages/about-us-our-story checked September 30, 2026
Backs: Markets
“straight to your door, anywhere in the US”
- mychicagosteak.com/pages/contact checked September 30, 2026
Backs: Support channels
“please call888-970-1118 ... please email us comments or suggestions by filling out the form below”
- mychicagosteak.com/pages/shipping checked September 30, 2026
Backs: Free delivery threshold, Next-day delivery
“FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS 199+ ... Over $199.99 FREE”
- mychicagosteak.com/policies/terms-of-service checked September 30, 2026
Backs: Headquarters, Legal entity
“The Service is controlled, operated and administered by Chicago Steak Company from our offices within the USA.”
Compiled from 7 source pages, checked September 30, 2026. We did not open an account.
What changed
- September 30, 2026: axisScores cost was 8.5, now 8.6
- September 30, 2026: axisScores trust was 9.0, now 8.9
Chicago Steak Company
A single US meat, seafood or gourmet gift order that needs to arrive quickly.